Best Pizza in Jersey City, NJ

11 Best Pizza in Jersey City, NJ

Embark on a delectable journey through Jersey City’s thriving food scene, where the pizza offerings steal the spotlight. From timeless Italian classics to authentic New York-style slices, the city’s pizza landscape is a culinary adventure waiting to be savored in “Chilltown.” Navigating through the plethora of options can be daunting, but fear not – here’s a curated list of the top pizza havens in Jersey City.

Delight your taste buds at these esteemed restaurants, where expertly crafted pies redefine pizza perfection. Save time and savor the best pizza in Jersey City, NJ, with this indispensable guide to gastronomic bliss.

1. Porta

Best Pizza in Jersey City, NJ

Photo by Ahmad No More:

Porta has been delighting pizza lovers since 2014 with its commitment to preparing authentic Neapolitan masterpieces. Elevating the pizza experience, they proudly offer in-house ricotta and mozzarella, ensuring a fresh and delicious base for their creations. Porta is one of the best pizza joints in Jersey City, offering a wide selection that caters to diverse tastes.

Pizza, with plentiful and perfectly balanced toppings, guarantees a satisfying culinary journey. Porta’s charming ambiance sets the stage for a relaxed and diverse atmosphere. For those seeking a unique taste experience, the Winter Betty pizza is a must-try, featuring crispy Brussels sprouts, luxurious goat cheese béchamel, aromatic thyme, garlic, Parmigiano Reggiano, extra virgin olive oil and a sprinkle of sea salt.

Kickstart your culinary adventure by tasting daily-made, fresh house-made ricotta with thinly sliced Italian bread. Porta’s dedication to excellence in both taste and atmosphere solidifies its position as the best pizza in Jersey City, NJ, offering patrons an unmatched dining experience.

 2. Krispy Pizza

For a unique pizza experience in the heart of New York and New Jersey, look no further than Crispy’s Pizza, an iconic family-owned restaurant with a heritage spanning five decades. A beacon for pizza lovers, this establishment is renowned for its consistently delicious offerings, earning praise from Brooklyn locals.

The allure of crispy pizzas goes beyond taste, as their wallet-friendly prices make it an attractive option for lunch or dinner. Enjoy the prime Grandma’s Pizza, a thin-crust Sicilian masterpiece featuring fresh mozzarella, homemade tomato sauce, basil, olive oil, and grated cheese. Enhance your dining experience by pairing it with the refreshing Balsamic Chicken Salad, concluding a refreshingly satisfying meal that captures the essence of Crispy Pizza cooking.

3. Razza Pizza Artigianale

Raza redefines pizza perfection with its advanced technologies and premium ingredients, earning its reputation as one of the finest pizza joints in the region. What really sets Raza apart is their commitment to craftsmanship, which is evident in the fact that they bake their own bread and make delicious butter in-house.

Setting a new standard for sophistication, they also cultivate their own yeast culture, a testament to their dedication to quality. Despite the high price, the sophisticated dining experience at Razza is unparalleled, justifying every penny spent.

Among his culinary masterpieces, Funghi Pizza stands out, a harmonious explosion of flavors that does not overpower the palate. From the carefully selected ingredients to the homemade bread, Razza’s is the epitome of high-class pizza cuisine, solidifying its position as the best pizza in Jersey City, NJ.

4. Two Boots

Best Pizza in Jersey City, NJ

Photo by Katerina Holmes:

Indulge your taste buds at Two Boots, a delectable pizzeria named after Italy and Louisiana’s distinctive boot-shaped geography. Located in the heart of Jersey City, this kid-friendly eatery is set to become your new pizza heaven. The delicious slices offered are both delicious and conveniently portable.

Two Boots distinguishes itself with whimsical and amusing decor, which sets it apart from other pizza establishments in the neighborhood. Ideal for refueling after the party, the joint is strategically located near the excellent bar.

For a culinary adventure, try the Bird or Buffalo Chicken Pizza, where the harmonious blend of jalapeños, Buffalo chicken, and velvety blue cheese dressing creates a spicy kick, pleasing your taste buds and satisfying your stomach. Elevate your pizza experience at Two Boots for a truly memorable dining pleasure.

5. Delenio

Famous for its unwavering commitment to using only the freshest ingredients, this Italian gem is a paradise for pizza lovers. The allure of Delennio’s lies not only in its delicious menu but also in the artistry of crafting a crust and flavor profile that satisfies the most discerning palate.

Step into this charming pizzeria to enjoy authentic, budget-friendly Italian cuisine Keep. The generously distributed prasad provides a satisfying feast without breaking the bank. The casual ambiance, adorned with attractive brick walls, adds to the overall warmth of this pizza haven.

Their signature vodka sauce is a must-try with the fresh mozzarella pizza, where the creamy vodka sauce takes center stage. Distinguished by its low acidity, high richness, spiciness, and subtle sweetness compared to traditional tomato sauce, this pizza is a culinary masterpiece. Additionally, delight your taste buds with the juiciness of their delicious, tangy, and tender meatballs for a truly indulgent experience.

Embark on a culinary journey at Delano’s, where every bite tells the story of the passion for quality that makes this Jersey City, Becomes the undisputed choice for the best pizza in NJ.

6. Roman Nose

Roman Noz specializes in simple and unique fresh Italian cuisine. Although they proudly offer a menu of basic Italian food, it is the careful preparation and exceptional quality of each dish that really sets them apart. If you’re looking for a premier pizza joint in Jersey City for a casual and fun experience, Roman Nose is your destination.

The intimate ambiance of the restaurant, adorned with cozy interiors, whimsical string lights, and attractive stained glass windows, exudes charm and homeliness. For a unique taste sensation, enjoy their Classic Margherita Pizza. Packed with flavor, the combination of fresh mozzarella, vibrant tomato sauce, and aromatic basil creates a symphony for your taste buds.

The thin and crispy crust elevates the experience, making it a contender for the title of best artisan pizza you’ve ever tasted. At Roman Noz, simplicity and excellence combine to create a culinary journey that goes beyond the ordinary, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers and connoisseurs alike.

7. Gino’s Pizzeria

Best Pizza in Jersey City, NJ

Photo by Engin Akyurt:

Established in 1976, Gino’s Pizzeria is an iconic family-run restaurant that epitomizes classic Italian-American cuisine. Nostalgia takes center stage as patrons enjoy traditional dishes, embarking on a delightful trip down memory lane similar to the culinary treasures prepared by grandmothers. The timeless atmosphere of the establishment further enhances this feeling, creating an authentic old-world pizza experience.

For an explosion of flavors reminiscent of home-cooked dishes, the Four Seasons Pizza tempts with an exquisite blend of mushrooms, artichokes, roasted peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil. Don’t miss the opportunity to taste their delicious buffalo wings with crispy celery sticks and rich thick blue cheese – truly a feast for the senses. Discover the heart and soul of Italian-American culinary excellence at Gino’s Pizzeria, known as the best pizza in Jersey City, NJ.

8. ITA Italian Kitchen

Savor the authentic flavors of Italy at ITA Italian Kitchen, a cozy gem gracing McGinley Square in 2020. A culinary destination that celebrates Italian culture, this Downtown Jersey City pizza joint offers a dining experience as rich as its diverse menu. Amidst the contemporary and cozy interior, taste the essence of Italy in every bite of their carefully crafted pizzas, salads, and pasta.

For a pizza adventure, dive into the Prosciutto di Parma, where a delicate blend of nutty ricotta, peppery arugula, and savory prosciutto creates a symphony of flavors. If you’re willing to eat more, enhance your experience with their Fettuccine Alfredo garnished with mixed mushrooms, Parmesan, and black pepper. Amp up the protein with optional chicken or shrimp, and let ITA Italian Kitchen transport you to the heart of Italian culinary excellence.

9. Rustique Pizza

Rustic Pizza, a charming family-owned eatery, stands as the epitome of pizza perfection in Jersey City, NJ, earning its reputation as the “Best Pizza in Jersey City.” Their commitment to the time-honored brick oven method sets them apart in the competitive pizza landscape of New Jersey and New York.

Decorated with rustic brick walls, the restaurant exudes a simple yet cozy ambiance. The undisputed star of their menu is the Four Cheese Pizza, a divine blend of mozzarella, fontino, pecorino romano, and shaved Parmesan that sits harmoniously on a crunchy crust.

Dances. This culinary masterpiece has not only mesmerized the taste buds, but has also garnered the coveted award for Best Pizza in Jersey City, NJ, but also for Rustic Pizza. For those looking for an addictive indulgence, Eggplant Parmigiana reigns supreme. Generously layered with hand-picked eggplant, homemade mozzarella, and delicious marinara, each slice is a symphony of flavors.

10. Tony Boloneys

Enjoy a fine dining experience at this casual establishment, where every meal becomes a sensory delight. The intimate space has charming interiors decorated in light colors, creating an inviting ambiance that enhances your meal. Despite its small size, this venue offers an unforgettable opportunity for both dine-in and takeout.

When it comes to culinary recommendations, Ay Dios Mio Pizza stands out as the epitome of flavor fusion. This top-tier pizza in Jersey City combines the comfort of mac and cheese with an exotic Mexican twist.

The harmonious blend of textures and the subtle kick of spiciness turn this pizza into a gastronomic masterpiece, ensuring that each slice is a journey through a symphony of flavors. Don’t miss the chance to taste this unique and delectable creation, as it undoubtedly adds a memorable touch to your dining experience.

11. Renato’s Pizza Masters

Best Pizza in Jersey City, NJ

Photo by Oleksandr P:

Since its inception in 1959, Renato’s Pizza Masters has solidified its status as an institution in Jersey City, earning the coveted title of “Best Pizza in Jersey City, NJ” among locals. Famous for its thin crust, piping hot slices, and irresistible cheesy pizzas, this long-standing Italian eatery on Central Avenue has become a favorite spot for pizza lovers.

The restaurant’s simple storefront matches the cozy interior, creating an ideal setting for solo diners or those enjoying a meal with family and friends. For a delectable experience, enjoy their signature Baked Ziti, featuring a harmonious blend of penne pasta, ricotta cheese, tomato sauce, and perfectly melted mozzarella.

Additionally, amp up your pizza thrill with the heavenly BBQ Chicken Bacon Cheddar Pizza, which features a delicious blend of grilled chicken, bacon, BBQ sauce, and the creamy richness of mozzarella cheese. Whether you’re strolling down Central Avenue or savoring a slice down the road, Renato’s Pizza Masters guarantees a memorable and delicious culinary journey.

Leave a Comment