Best Pizza in Syracuse, NY

11 Best Pizza in Syracuse, NY

Finding the best pizza in Syracuse, NY is easy when armed with the right knowledge. Whether you’re a resident looking for a delectable lunch spot or a traveler craving the ultimate pizza adventure, Syracuse has it all.

This guide reveals the top-rated pizza establishments in the city and what sets them apart. Explore these culinary gems to taste the best pizza in Syracuse, NY, and treat your taste buds to an unforgettable experience.

1. Apizza Regionale

Best Pizza in Syracuse, NY

Photo by Jane Doan:

Apizza Regionale, known for serving delicious Neapolitan-style pizzas since 2016. When it comes to authentic Italian cuisine, this family-owned joint is unmatched in the area. The charming ambiance strikes a perfect balance between casual and modern, industrial-chic designs that set the stage for a memorable dining experience.

Whether you’re planning a lively night out with friends or a romantic date, Apizza Regional caters to all occasions. The low lighting and cozy booths create an intimate atmosphere, making it a perfect place for a special evening. Don’t miss their pièce de résistance: the Syracuse Apizza.

This delectable creation features a thin, crispy crust generously coated with fresh San Marzano tomatoes in a rich sauce made from fresh San Marzano tomatoes. Topped with locally sourced mozzarella cheese, it’s a symphony of flavors complemented by delicious Italian sausage, peppers, and onions.

For a taste of the best of Syracuse, Apizza Regional is your go-to place. It’s no wonder locals and visitors alike acknowledge it as the best pizza in Syracuse, NY.

2. Nick’s Pizzeria

Nick’s Pizzeria is an iconic family-owned establishment famous for its delicious wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizza. Located in Syracuse, it is one of the best pizza joints in the city for several compelling reasons. The blend of modernity and tradition is evident in every aspect of this charming eatery, which has gained a devoted local following.

Their specialty is in preparing thinly sliced pizzas decorated with lots of delicious toppings. In addition to pizza, the menu features tempting options like lasagna and pasta, complemented by a diverse selection of beers.

For an unforgettable culinary experience, enjoy their signature pies; A New York-style masterpiece featuring fresh mozzarella, savory Italian sausage, sweet red peppers, and aromatic oregano. It is a must-try for anyone who steps into this gastronomic paradise.

 3. Varsity Pizza

Varsity Pizza is a beloved, family-owned pizzeria with a rich history dating back to 1926. Their enduring commitment to creating exceptional Italian cuisine is reflected in every meal. The restaurant exudes a charming vintage ambiance, adorned in vibrant university colors that exude a nostalgic charm.

It is a perfect place for a casual pizza outing, where you can create memorable memories with friends and family. The house specialty is a must-try. This delicious pizza is a blend of flavors, including juicy pepperoni, delicious Italian sausage, crispy green peppers, and robust mushrooms.

The thin, crispy crust is kissed with a touch of garlic, enhancing the flavor experience. A rich blend of mozzarella and provolone cheeses provides a creamy richness that pairs perfectly with the toppings. For an unforgettable pizza feast, Varsity Pizza is the preferred destination.

4. Twin Trees Too

Best Pizza in Syracuse, NY

Photo by Diamond Multimedia:

Twin Trees Too, a cherished family-friendly Italian restaurant, has been delighting patrons with its delectable Italian dishes since its establishment in 1957. Renowned for offering the finest Syracuse pizza for families, this establishment boasts a classic and inviting ambiance, making it an ideal venue for hosting various events, including birthday parties.

Its spacious yet intimate setting is enhanced by warm lighting, ensuring a cozy dining experience. Nestled inconspicuously among the houses on the street, the alluring aroma of freshly baked pizzas guides eager diners to this hidden gem. Among their stellar offerings, the Loaded Bake pizza reigns supreme, adorned with a tantalizing medley of pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, and mushrooms.

What truly elevates this culinary masterpiece is the harmonious marriage of creamy mozzarella and sharp cheddar cheeses, resulting in a sublime fusion of tangy and savory notes that is simply unparalleled.

5. Paladino’s Pizza

Paladino Pizza, an iconic establishment in the Northern Lights Shopping Center, has been delighting patrons with authentic Italian food since its inception in 1980. This local gem stands as a favorite destination for pizza lovers, offering an experience that blends delicious flavors.

A warm, family-friendly atmosphere. Comfortable booths, vintage decor, and welcoming staff with a palpable sense of hospitality ensure that every visit is memorable. As far as pizza goes, Paladino’s in Syracuse, NY ranks supreme, with a signature “Original Supreme” featuring zesty tomato sauce, melted mozzarella cheese, and a savory blend of onions, mushrooms, peppers, and olives.

And let’s not forget their delicious wings, which are the perfect accompaniment to your pizza enjoyment. Without a doubt, Paladino Pizza shows itself as the undisputed champion for the best pizza in Syracuse, NY.

6. Toss & Fire Wood Fired Pizza

Toss & Fire Wood Fired Pizza, a beloved family-owned pizzeria chain established in 2015, has become a standout choice for pizza lovers in Syracuse. What sets this establishment apart is its atmosphere and extraordinary blend of tastes. The modern interior features a welcoming mix of warm woods and industrial-chic accents, creating a chic yet charming ambiance.

The menu showcases a range of pizzas, both classic and inventive, all cooked to perfection in the wood-red oven, giving them a distinctive, delectable flavor prole. To complement these delicious creations, Toss & Fire offers an extensive selection of craft beers and wines, carefully crafted to enhance the pizza experience.

Among their scrumptious offerings, the Margherita Pizza stands out as a masterpiece, coordinating fresh mozzarella, juicy vine-ripened tomatoes, and aromatic basil in an awless symphony of flavors and textures. Paired with a glass of your favorite Italian red wine, it transforms into a culinary delight, solidifying its position as one of the best pizzas in the city.

7. Pies Guys Pizzeria

Best Pizza in Syracuse, NY

Photo by Peter Benedetti:

If you are looking for the best pizza in Syracuse, NY, Pies Guys is your best choice. This local pizzeria has earned a stellar reputation for good reason. Their Classic Margherita Pie is an absolute must-try, with its delicious combination of tangy tomato sauce and creamy cheese.

The addition of fresh basil and oregano adds a delightful kick that ties the entire dish together beautifully. But Pizza Guys isn’t just about pizza – their extensive menu offers something for everyone, from mouthwatering wings and hearty subs to satisfying calzones, delicious gyros, crisp salads, and even delicious seafood options. Too. And the best part? The portions are generous, ensuring you always get your money’s worth. Don’t miss this Syracuse gem!

8. Twin Trees Restaurant

Twin Trees Restaurant stands out as a local pizza gem, renowned for its warm and family-friendly ambiance. The unassuming yet inviting setting creates the perfect backdrop for gatherings with loved ones. What truly sets them apart is their commitment to generous portions and bold flavors.

Their pizzas are a testament to this, with a tantalizing array of toppings and seasonings that leave taste buds dancing. A must-try is their classic Sicilian, a masterpiece featuring a unique sauce infused with red and white wine, elevating the traditional mozzarella and cheddar cheese blend.

Topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and peppers, each bite is a symphony of taste. To complete the experience, a refreshing beer or a glass of wine is the perfect companion. Twin Trees is not just a pizza joint, it’s an unforgettable culinary journey.

9. Johnny Mac’s Pizzeria & Deli

Johnny Mac’s Pizzeria & Deli in Syracuse, NY is a hidden gem for those seeking an authentic taste of Italy. This family-owned joint offers a casual, neighborhood eatery charm reminiscent of the streets of Italy.

Each dish on the menu is lovingly prepared using family recipes passed down for generations. Portions are generous, evoking the feeling of an Italian grandmother’s kitchen. Their famous Johnny Mac Special is a must-try – a delicious blend of hand-tossed dough, homemade marinara sauce, and a harmonious blend of mozzarella and provolone cheeses.

With luscious Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and bell peppers, this is a true crowd-pleaser. For the best pizza in Syracuse, NY, look no further than Johnny Mac’s.

10. A Mano Kitchen & Bar

Mano Kitchen & Bar is a fine gem of a family-owned Italian restaurant, where rustic charm meets modest elegance. The place exudes warmth with its exposed brick walls, dim lighting, potted plants, and visible pipes, creating a pleasant and inviting atmosphere for dining. What sets this place apart is its impeccable cleanliness and cozy ambiance, making it an ideal spot for a romantic date.

The attention to detail extends to their culinary offerings, where every dish is designed to be as delicious as it looks. A standout recommendation is their Prosciutto and Arugula Pizza, a culinary masterpiece with a thin, crispy crust adorned with luscious garlic sauce, savory prosciutto, spicy arugula and gooey mozzarella cheese.

The prosciutto provides a delightful smoky saltiness, while the arugula provides a vibrant, peppery flavor, and the creamy garlic sauce adds a wonderful depth to the ensemble. It is a symphony of flavors that makes your taste buds dance with joy.

11. Tangy Tomato Pizzeria

Best Pizza in Syracuse, NY

Photo by Valeria Boltneva:

Tangy Tomato Pizzeria, an iconic local gem in Syracuse, NY, stands as pizza heaven for aficionados wanting a taste of both Chicago deep-dish and New York-style pie. Known as a provider of the finest pizza in Syracuse, Tangy Tomato’s mastery of deep dishes is unmatched. Each piece is a harmonious blend of rich, gooey cheese and impeccably fresh toppings, expertly cooked for an explosion of flavor.

Flat pizzas, boasting an excellent crispiness, vie for attention and often steal the limelight. Be it a leisurely gathering with friends or a craved morning commute, Tangy Tomato provides the perfect setting.

The Margherita Pizza, their pièce de résistance, is a delectable creation that includes classic tomato sauce, luscious mozzarella, and fragrant basil leaves, resulting in a symphony of flavors that embodies the essence of this extraordinary pizzeria. For a unique pizza experience, Tangy Tomato Pizzeria is the undisputed symbol of Syracuse’s culinary excellence.

Leave a Comment