Best Pizza in Wellesley, MA

11 Best Pizza in Wellesley, MA [2024]

Satisfy your pizza craving in Wellesley, Massachusetts, a charming small town that punches above its weight in culinary delights. Within its quaint streets are located pizzerias that promise to take your taste buds to new heights.

Wellesley offers a diverse pizza experience, ranging from the timeless allure of classic Italian flavors to the iconic taste of New York-style pies. What sets this city apart is the opportunity to create your own perfect pizza masterpiece, allowing you to customize your toppings and crust to your heart’s desire. At Wellesley, every bite is a celebration of pizza perfection.

Don’t miss your chance to experience pizza heaven in this hidden gem of the city. Find the best pizza in Wellesley, MA, and satisfy your craving at these exceptional eateries.

1. Comella’s

Best Pizza in Wellesley, MA

Photo by Engin Akyurt:

Comella, an iconic family-owned pizza chain, has firmly established itself as an icon of pizza excellence throughout Massachusetts, with an impressive network of 11 locations. Since the 1980s, this pizzeria has honed its craft, demonstrating unparalleled expertise in the art of pizza making.

Their enduring commitment to time-tested recipes, combined with decades of experience, consistently delivers the finest Wellesley pizza experience. The Olivia Rose Pie is an exceptional recommendation, a triumph in culinary creativity.

With the strong meaty flavor of the buffalo chicken topping, this pizza achieves a harmonious balance. The addition of creamy blue cheese enhances its flavor, making this a definite top-tier pizza at Wellesley.

Comella is not just a pizza joint; It is a culinary institution that creates a delicious legacy in every bite. Enjoy the excellence that defines the best pizza in Wellesley, MA.

2. Wellesley North End Pizza

Wellesley North End Pizza is known as a premier pizza joint, celebrated for its delicious subs and remarkable brick-oven pizzas. The menu has versatility with options like whole wheat flour and thin crust, ensuring a delightful culinary experience.

The mix of classic and innovative pies offers a comprehensive journey through pizza perfection. Enjoy timeless favorites like Hawaiian and Garden Pie, or elevate your palate with the Neapolitana Pizza featuring distinctive eggplant toppings on soft dough.

However, the pinnacle of taste lies in the Meat Lovers Pizza, earning this establishment a reputation as the best establishment in Wellesley. Pepperoni and beef patty-infused dough, complemented by Romano cheese, creates a deliciously meaty and creamy dish that really sets this pizza place apart.

3. Old School Italian Pizzeria

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Wellesley, look no further than this old-school Italian pizzeria with charming outdoor seating. Their classic and modern pies are crafted to perfection, featuring a delightful range of flavors that will satisfy any pizza enthusiast.

Pepperoni Pie offers a comforting dose of familiar flavors, while adventurous folks can enjoy the unique taste of Big Mac Pizza. For a taste-pleasing experience, don’t miss the Back to School Pie.

This masterpiece combines mozzarella and feta cheese, creating a creamy sensation, while tomatoes and Kalamata olives take the pie to unparalleled heights.

With fresh ingredients and a charming atmosphere, this pizzeria stands as the undisputed best pizza joint in Wellesley, MA. Treat yourself to an unforgettable pizza experience that is beyond the ordinary.

4. Mark’s Pizza & Subs

Best Pizza in Wellesley, MA

Photo by Leonardo Luz:

Marx Pizza, an iconic eatery that started in 1977, has stood the test of time, enthralling patrons with its timeless cuisine and unique pizza offerings. Boasting both classic and specialty pies, each bite reflects decades of culinary excellence.

The longevity of Mark’s Pizza is a testament to its unwavering commitment to taste and tradition. A must-try is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which has a delicious blend of meaty goodness from a juicy boneless chicken on a perfectly seasoned dough.

Filled with the velvety texture of blue cheese, this pizza is a culinary masterpiece that continues to enthrall diners, showcasing over 40 years of gastronomic delight.

5. Fiorella’s Express

Located in Wellesley, Massachusetts, Fiorella Express has become the epitome of authentic Neapolitan-style pizza. With three other locations in the state, this eatery has earned its reputation as the best pizza joint in Wellesley.

Embark on a captivating journey through Italy within the confines of this charming location, where the staff prepares pizzas using premium Italian ingredients like prosciutto and Pecorino Romano, following original recipes.

The Margherita pizza is a must-try, with a dough that tastes fresh, along with a delicious tomato-basil sauce. The creamy goodness of mozzarella and pecorino romano enhances this culinary masterpiece.

Immerse yourself in an authentic Italian-inspired ambiance, making Fiorella Express the top choice for a unique dining experience. Enjoy the best pizza in Wellesley, MA, and enjoy every moment of this gastronomic delight.

6. Domino’s Pizza

This pizza chain, which originated in Michigan in the 1960s, has become a nationwide sensation with more than 6,000 locations. Famous for its delicious classic and modern pizzas, this establishment stands out because of its meticulous pizza preparation process.

The skilled team is busy hand-tossing the dough, creating options like gluten-free, thin, or Brooklyn-style crusts. Following the foundation of your favorite sauce, a blend of fresh ingredients is carefully added, resulting in a pizza masterpiece.

Located in the heart of downtown Wellesley, this joint is known for serving great pizza. For an extraordinary experience, enjoy the Extravaganza, featuring the delicious meaty flavors of pepperoni and ham topping, topped with 100% real mozzarella. It’s a pizza lover’s dream come true.

7. Square MFG. Co

Best Pizza in Wellesley, MA

Photo by Horizon Content:

Located in Wellesley, MA, this pizza joint serves as a beacon for Detroit-style pizza lovers. The casual setting belies the gastronomic delights within, where culinary experts create mouth-watering square pies that redefine pizza perfection.

The key to their excellence lies in meticulous preparation – the freshly made dough is left to rise overnight, resulting in a crispy yet delightfully chewy crust. Dedicated staff carefully layer the cheese and accompany the incredible sauces that crown the composition, ensuring that each piece is a symphony of flavors.

The star of the show, the Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza, is a culinary masterpiece. The crisp meat matches seamlessly with the creamy cheese mixture, while a luscious ranch drizzle and buffalo sauce elevate the entire experience into barbecue-inspired bliss.

This pizza joint’s commitment to rich flavors and unparalleled quality establishes it as the best pizza in Wellesley, MA, inspiring patrons to return for these delectable square dishes. Enjoy the excellence of Detroit-style pie and a taste of heaven with every unforgettable meal.

8. Hearth Pizzeria

Established in 2015, Hearth Pizzeria has become a culinary cornerstone in Wellesley, celebrated for its exquisite Neapolitan-style pizza. What sets it apart in the bustling pizza scene is its bold combinations of ingredients, creating pies that are a feast for the senses. In particular, the Fig, Prosciutto, and Blue Cheese Pizza, dressed with arugula and a luscious red wine glaze, is a symphony of flavors.

Buffalo Chicken Pie delights with a harmonious blend of blue cheese dressing, garlic oil, and hot sauce. Catering to a variety of preferences, Hearth Pizzeria offers gluten-free and vegan options, including the health-conscious Green Goddess Pizza, which features fresh spinach and broccoli-infused dough, topped with creamy cheese.

In a landscape filled with pizza options, Hearth Pizzeria stands out for its exceptional culinary artistry, making it a must-see for pizza lovers in the area.

9. The Pizza Shop at South Natick

Located in Wellesley, MA, this family-owned establishment has earned its reputation as one of the best pizza joints in town. Along with a diverse menu of oven-hot pies, it stands out with its unique build-your-own pizza options. What sets this place apart is its culinary journey around the world; Each bite takes you on a delicious adventure.

Taking inspiration from international cuisine, the pizzas include exotic creations like the Mediterranean Misto and Marengo Pie. Want a taste of Brazil? Enjoy a Brasileira pizza adorned with an extraordinary corn topping.

Embark on a culinary journey through Portugal with Portuguese pizza filled with ham, eggs, and tomatoes. Pizza, regardless of your choice, is a symphony of authentic flavors, creating a unique gastronomic experience. Don’t miss the classic Hawaiian pizza, where the tart pineapple topping is perfectly complemented with the delicious ham, ensuring an unforgettable taste sensation.

This pizza haven is undoubtedly a favorite spot for pizza lovers for the best pizza in Wellesley, MA.

10. Bill’s Pizzeria

Bill’s Pizzeria, a culinary icon since the 1970s, has become synonymous with exceptional pizza experiences. Renowned for their commitment to quality, the staff prepares each dough from scratch daily, resulting in pies that are consistently fresh and full of vibrant flavors.

Using only the finest vegetables and meat adds to their offering. What sets Bill apart is his rich culinary heritage, with time-tested recipes passed down in the same family for generations. For a unique taste sensation, enjoy the Spanakopizza.

The dough has a creamy color, which matches with the delicious cheese mixture. Enriched with garlic and spinach, this pizza is beyond the ordinary, offering a heavenly culinary experience that tantalizes the palate and is a testament to the enduring legacy of Bill’s Pizzeria.

11. La Toscana’s Pizzeria

Best Pizza in Wellesley, MA

Photo by Mikhail Nilov:

La Toscana’s Pizzeria in Wellesley, MA, is best known as a fine dining destination, known for its exceptional pastas and diverse array of classic and modern pizzas. This casual eatery also offers a variety of beverages like coffee, juices, and smoothies to coffee lovers.

The real magic lies in the authenticity of their Italian pizzas. From Napoletana to Margherita and Parmigiana, each bite takes you to the heart of Italy. The staff carefully follows original recipes, ensuring each pizza is packed with genuine flavor.

For a deviation from Italian classics, check out the charming Le Special Pizza. The BBQ Chicken Ranch Pizza is a revelation, featuring crispy meat toppings drenched in delicious barbecue sauce. The Chicago Deep Dish, with its minimalist but divine combination of cheese and tomato sauce, is a must-try.

However, the real star of the menu is the Diavola, considered the best pizza in Wellesley, MA. The incredible softness of the dough is a revelation in itself, complemented by the slightly tangy tomato sauce.

Leave a Comment