Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn, NY

11 Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn, NY [2024]

Indulge your culinary cravings in the diverse borough of Brooklyn, where a delectable array of Italian eateries awaits you at every turn. From delicious pasta dishes to heavenly tiramisu, this city stands as a foodie’s paradise.

Dive into an epic journey through the gastronomic landscape of Brooklyn, where there is a tempting selection of Italian cuisine around every corner.

Enhance your experience with our curated list of the best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, NY, sure to be an unforgettable culinary adventure that captures the essence of this vibrant borough.

1. Zeppola Bakery

Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn, NY

Photo by BULBFISH:

It is a neighborhood gem that is famous for preparing exquisite Italian baked goods and dishes. A paradise for dough lovers, this establishment offers a delicious range of pastries, from charming bomboloni to intricate sfogliatella.

For a heartier meal, enjoy the taste of pizza or focaccia, and don’t miss the Prosciutto and Arugula Panini – an absolute delight with each delicious bite.

Enhance your experience with a cup of perfectly prepared Cappuccino. The Caprese sandwich, adorned with diced tomatoes, basil chutney, and creamy mozzarella, comes out as a palate-pleasing masterpiece, making this eatery a top choice among the best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, NY.

2. Piccola Cucina Estiatorio

Piccola Cucina Estiatorio, a prestigious member of the renowned Piccola Cucina group, is one of the best Italian restaurants, offering an authentic Sicilian culinary experience. Owned and operated by Chef Philippe Gardione, this eatery is celebrated for its excellent Sicilian cuisine, paired with a selection of both local and imported wines.

Using genuine Italian ingredients, Guardione’s commitment to tradition shines through in each dish. For a unique Italian food adventure, taste the Fusiloni di Gragnano Scampi, a heavenly delight where pasta is fused with rich langoustine meat, enhanced by the addition of burrata cheese and cherry tomatoes, making it pasta perfection in Brooklyn. Symbolizes.

3. Michael’s of Brooklyn

Indulge your senses at Michael’s of Brooklyn, a quintessential family-owned gem among Brooklyn’s Italian restaurants. Elevating classic Italian cuisine to an art form, this eatery boasts a culinary heritage rich with generations-old family recipes. Their pasta, a true standout, is garnished with an excellent home-cooked sauce that is so irresistible they even bottle it to savor at home.

Enjoy main plates of carefully prepared meat and seafood, featuring traditional Italian ingredients that transport you to the heart of Italy. As a grand finale, treat yourself to divine Italian desserts, including velvety tortoni and classic tiramisu. Among the culinary triumphs, Veal Scallopini Marsala takes the spotlight.

Immerse your taste buds in the tender meat, with a slightly tangy flavor thanks to its Marsala wine base. The addition of mushrooms, prosciutto, and onions transforms this dish into an authentic masterpiece, making Michael’s of Brooklyn a must-visit among the best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, NY.

4. Pisillo Italian Panini

Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn, NY

Photo by kei photo:

Located in Brooklyn, this eatery has been delighting customers with its exquisite paninis since 2012. The key to their culinary success lies in the customization and vegetarian options that cater to a variety of tastes. Famous for serving the finest Italian food in Brooklyn, this establishment is known for its commitment to quality.

Owners Carmelo and Antonella Nazzaro prioritize excellence, sourcing their bread locally from a well-established Brooklyn bakery. Adding to the experience, only premium Italian cold cuts imported from Italy grace the Paninis. A must-try is the Piscillo Panini, where Prosciutto di Parma and Porchetta bufala harmonize with mozzarella and roasted peppers, creating a symphony of flavors that will undoubtedly satisfy your cravings.

5. Sottocasa Pizzeria

Opened in 2011, Sottocasa Pizzeria in downtown Brooklyn has solidified its reputation as one of the area’s premier Italian eateries. Famous for its meticulous pizza preparation, the restaurant sources flour and tomatoes directly from Italy to ensure an authentic taste. The use of fresh US-sourced cheese further enhances the quality.

The pizzas are carefully crafted, with these premium ingredients added to a gluten-free crust option if desired, and then cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. In addition to their excellent Neapolitan pies, the antipasti offerings are equally delicious.

One of the best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, NY, Salsiccia Pizza is a standout, a paradise for meat lovers, featuring delicious Italian sausage topped with mozzarella and basil. Sottocasa Pizzeria stands as an icon of authentic Italian culinary excellence in Brooklyn.

6. Scalini Fedeli

Scalini Fedeli is one of two locations in New York specifically for fans of Tuscany-inspired cuisine with a modern twist. Located in the heart of Brooklyn, this luxurious eatery offers a sophisticated ambiance that complements its innovative Italian cuisine.

A must-try is the pappardelle, which features a delectable blend of braised veal and pork shank ragu, enhanced by orange and a hint of mascarpone. The Sorbetto is a revelation, showcasing lemon and coconut sorbet with rum-glazed pineapple.

For an exquisite experience, enjoy the Soft Egg Yolk Raviolo, where perfectly cooked pasta meets a delicious egg yolk and truffle butter sauce, topped with grated black truffle – an exquisite symphony of flavors that Scalini is the epitome of Fedeli’s cooking.

7. Oregano

Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn, NY

Photo by Ronmar Lacamiento:

Enjoy the culinary delights of Williamsburg’s famous Oregano, a haven for Neapolitan pizza and pasta lovers. Located in the heart of Brooklyn, this gem stands out with its delicious offerings and diverse vegetarian menu. Locals unanimously laud it as Brooklyn’s premier Italian eatery and with good reason.

At Oregano, a symphony of flavors awaits, pleasing every palate. The Margherita alla Oscar promises a classic pizza experience, while the Pesto Pizza offers a modern twist, showcasing the flavor of pasta atop a delicious crust. Pasta lovers can enjoy the richness of the spaghetti and meatballs or the perfection of the lasagna bolognese. An exceptional recommendation is the marinara pie – a winning masterpiece.

Crafted on the canvas of San Marzano tomato sauce, its slightly tart essence matches the aromatic blend of garlic and oregano, transforming each bite into a culinary symphony. Oregano is unquestionably a paradise for those looking for the best Italian culinary experience in Brooklyn, NY.

8. San Carlo Osteria Piemonte

Located in the heart of Brooklyn, this restaurant transports diners to the Piedmont region of Italy with its array of classic dishes. A culinary paradise, it boasts an extensive all-Italian wine selection and craft cocktails. Known for authenticity, it is a favorite spot for the best Italian cuisine in town.

Start your day with Uova Benedettine, Italy’s twist on Eggs Benedict, a delightful morning starter. For lunch, try Spaghetti alla Carbonara filled with creamy Pecorino Romano. As the sun sets, enjoy Mandilia al Cervo, featuring silky pasta dressed with braised venison ragu.

For pasta lovers, the Tagliatelle al Funghi, a showcase of pasta consisting of seafood with shrimp and porcini mushrooms, promises a delectable culinary journey.

9. Front Street Pizza

Front Street Pizza, this is a Brooklyn gem known for its exquisite pizzas, pasta, and Italian-inspired sandwiches. This eatery attracts with an extensive offering, inviting patrons to savor a symphony of flavors at every meal. Start your culinary journey with an Italian-inspired sandwich adorned with a blend of fresh mozzarella and salami.

For a celebration of seafood, dive into the Linguini with Clam Sauce, where ocean notes dance on your palate. The pièce de résistance lies in the diverse selection of Italian pies. The margaritas and calzones full of fresh, vibrant flavors promise a culinary symphony that will leave you spellbound.

However, the undisputed star is the meat lasagna – a gastronomic masterpiece where rich tomato sauce and delicious meat are harmoniously entwined with al dente pasta. Are. Equipped with a velvety cheese topping, each forkful is a journey into Italian culinary bliss at one of the best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, NY.

10. Kesté Pizza & Vino

The eatery, with two additional locations in New York, is known for its exceptional Neapolitan pies and an inclusive menu featuring vegan and gluten-free options. Owner Roberto Caporuccio demonstrates unique pizza-making skills, drawing inspiration from his training in Italy, specifically Naples, and under the guidance of master pizzaiolo like Antonio Starita.

The result is a culinary masterpiece, a delicious pizza full of authentic and fresh flavors. The marinara pizza, a standout recommendation, transports diners to culinary nirvana with its slightly tart dough, rich tomato sauce, oregano, and creamy Grana Padano cheese. Caporuccio’s commitment to using the finest ingredients ensures a truly spectacular dining experience.

11. Macosa Trattoria

Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn, NY

Photo by Shameel mukkath:

Macosa Trattoria is celebrated for its delicious antipasti and attractive Italian main plates. This exclusive eatery has an impressive selection of all-Italian wines, enhancing the dining experience with perfect pairings. The secret of the authenticity of the plates lies in the careful adherence to original recipes by dedicated staff using traditional Italian ingredients that transport diners to the heart of Italy.

Enjoy Rigatoni Pomodoro, where San Marzano tomatoes create a mouth-watering symphony mixed with Tulsi. The Bucatini Amatriciana is a masterpiece, featuring a luscious pecorino romano cheese coating and tantalizing guanciale. For health-conscious patrons, Macosa Trattoria accommodates gluten-free and vegetarian preferences upon request, ensuring a culinary delight for every taste.

Renowned as one of the finest Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, this establishment attracts connoisseurs with its commitment to authenticity and diverse menu. Tagliatelle is one of the must-try dishes at one of the best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, NY. There’s Al Funghi, a sensory masterpiece that tantalizes the taste buds with its white wine-infused pasta.

Citric undertones create an unforgettable flavor profile, complemented by the harmonious marriage of porcini mushrooms and olive oil. Makosa Trattoria is more than a dining experience; It is a journey through the culinary landscape of Italy, carefully decorated with words of authenticity, tradition, and unique taste.


Leave a Comment